‹ Back

What Should I Ask Before Hiring a Pilates Instructor?

How to Decide Which Option Is Right for You

 

 

 

Hiring a Pilates instructor isn't just about finding someone who can teach exercises. You're choosing someone to help you better understand your body and know how to react when something feels off. A good instructor should leave you feeling more confident, not more confused.

Whether you're dealing with back pain, recovering from an injury, or simply looking for more personalized guidance, here are the questions I'd recommend asking before deciding who to work with.

 

 

Have You Worked With My Specific Issue Before?

This is usually the first question I recommend asking.

 

If you have a particular concern, like a shoulder injury or knee arthritis, it's reasonable to ask whether they've worked with something similar.

 

But don't automatically cross someone off your list if they say no.

 

A good follow-up question is:

"What do you do if you haven't worked with someone who has this issue before?"

 

This answer tells you a lot. For me, that means learning more. I'll review the current research and, with your permission, communicate with your healthcare team when that's helpful. I'll make sure I understand what's been recommended, what should be avoided, and how we can work within those guidelines.

 

Right from the beginning, I'm looking for clues about whether our work is helping. When something feels better, we'll lean into that. If things aren't improving, or they get worse, that's important information too. We'll talk about what we're both noticing, and if it's clear you need something beyond my scope, I'll refer you to the right healthcare provider.

 

I know I don't have every answer, and I don't think you should expect any instructor to. What you do want is someone who's willing to keep learning, pay attention to how your body responds, and involve other professionals when that's the right next step.

 

 

What Makes Your Approach Different?

 

Ask how the instructor personalizes their sessions. Most exercises aren't inherently good or bad. The question is whether they're the right fit for you.

 

Many of my clients have already tried Pilates classes, YouTube videos, or other workouts before they find me. In many cases, they were doing exercises that made sense for what they had going on.

 

The difference was in the details.

 

Maybe...

• no one noticed a small adjustment that completely changed how the movement felt.
• they got good at the first exercise but never progressed beyond it.
• they were given too many exercises, so it felt overwhelming and eventually they stopped doing them altogether.
• they learned an exercise but never connected it back to the movements they actually wanted to do in everyday life.

 

One of the most common things I hear is,

"I've done this exercise before, but it's never felt like this."

 

That usually isn't because it's a brand new exercise. It's because someone is finally paying attention to how they're doing it.

 

I'm constantly watching for movement patterns, compensations, and small details that can change how an exercise feels and how much you get out of it. As your body changes, the exercises change too. My job is to keep paying attention, make adjustments in real time, and help you understand why we're making them.

 

 

How Do You Continue Learning?

 

Certifications matter. Experience matters. Continuing education matters too.

 

Someone who was certified recently may have very current information but less experience applying it. Someone who's been teaching for twenty years has valuable experience, but I also want to know they're still learning. Our understanding of movement continues to evolve, and good instructors should evolve with it.

 

I also appreciate instructors who study more than one area. Whether that's Pilates, strength training, yoga, biomechanics, pain science, functional movement, or another movement discipline, different perspectives help us think more critically about what will best serve the person in front of us.

 

The goal isn't to collect certifications. It's to stay curious enough to keep helping people well.

 

 

What Does Working Together Actually Look Like?

 

This is where you get to ask the practical questions. Find out how scheduling works, whether you'll meet at the same time each week, what happens if you travel, whether they offer memberships or packages, how to get started, and whether sessions are virtual, in a studio, or in your home.

 

These questions might not seem as important as experience or certifications, but they matter. The best movement program is one that fits into your real life. If the logistics create unnecessary stress, it's much harder to stay consistent.

 

 

A Couple Questions for You

 

After you've had a conversation with a potential instructor, take a few minutes to reflect. The answers to these questions can tell you just as much as anything they said.

 

Do I feel like I'm in good hands?

 

Did they listen? Did they explain things in a way that made sense? Did you leave feeling like they understood both your goals and your concerns?

 

You should feel like you're working with someone who's paying attention to you, not following a script.

 

Do I think I'll enjoy working with this person?

 

That might sound less important than experience or certifications, but I don't think it is.

 

Your relationship with your instructor becomes part of your relationship with movement. If you enjoy your sessions, feel understood, and look forward to showing up, you're much more likely to stay consistent.

 

And consistency is where meaningful change happens.

 

 

The Bottom Line

 

Choosing a Pilates instructor is about more than certifications or years of experience. You're looking for someone who can explain things clearly, adapt to your individual needs, and help you feel like you're making progress.

 

The right instructor should help you better understand your body, not leave you guessing about what to do next. Over time, that understanding builds confidence, and confidence changes how you move through your everyday life.

 

The goal isn't to become better at Pilates. It's to have a body that quietly supports the life you want to live… whether that's carrying your grandchildren, hiking on vacation, gardening all afternoon, or simply sitting through a meeting without thinking about your back.